Quick Facts
- Friday at Kirtipur
- Sudurpaschim 125/6 beat Kathmandu 118/7 by 7 runs; Chitwan 92/6 beat Janakpur 88 by 4 wickets
- Last five matches
- Highest total in ten innings was 136; three innings ended below 100
- Standout bowling
- Sandeep Lamichhane 6 wickets including a hat-trick vs Pokhara; Ranjit Kumar 3 for 2 vs Janakpur
- Points table
- Sudurpaschim 10, Lumbini 9 through; Kathmandu 8, Chitwan 7, Biratnagar 6 fight for two spots
- Remaining matches
- Biratnagar vs Lumbini, Sat 14 Nov 5:00 PM NST; Chitwan vs Karnali, Sun 15 Nov 12:30 PM NST; Kathmandu vs Pokhara, Sun 15 Nov 5:00 PM NST
The bowlers have taken over the Nepal Premier League. On Friday at the TU International Cricket Ground in Kirtipur, batsmen struggled for runs in both matches of the day, and the slow pitch is now the biggest talking point of Season 3: praised by the bowlers who are thriving on it, and questioned by the batsmen who cannot buy a run on it.
Five matches, no total past 136
Friday told the story twice over. In the first match, Sudurpaschim Royals made only 125 for 6 in their 20 overs, and Kathmandu Gorkhas still could not chase it, finishing on 118 for 7 to lose by seven runs. In the second match, Janakpur Bolts were bowled out for 88, and Chitwan Rhinos needed 17.2 overs and lost six wickets chasing a target of 89. Two matches, four innings, and not one side reached 130.
That was not a one-day blip. It was the fifth low-scoring match in a row at the same ground, and the pattern is now impossible to ignore. The bowlers are not just winning matches at Kirtipur. They are deciding them.
The numbers from the last five completed matches make the point better than any opinion could. On Tuesday, Sudurpaschim scored 120 for 9 and Janakpur were bowled out for 93 in 19.5 overs. On Thursday, Pokhara Avengers were dismissed for 132 and Biratnagar Kings needed 19.2 overs and six wickets to get there, and in the second match of that day Karnali Yaks were bowled out for 105 in 19.2 overs while Lumbini Lions lost six wickets chasing 106. Then came Friday: 125 for 6 against 118 for 7, and 88 all out against 92 for 6.
Ten innings, and the highest total among them was 136. Three of the ten innings ended below 100. Three of the five matches were won by the side batting second, and in the two exceptions Sudurpaschim defended totals of 120 and 125. In a format where 170 to 180 is considered a par score in most franchise leagues, the Kirtipur pitch is producing something entirely different.
The contrast with the one big batting day of the recent run is striking. In Match 19, Pokhara Avengers posted 217, powered by a century from Canadian opener Yuvraj Samra. That innings showed that runs are possible at this ground. What the five matches since have shown is how rarely they come, and how much work they take when they do.
The bowlers who are making it happen
Friday belonged, above all, to the bowlers who understood the surface quickest. Chitwan's Ranjit Kumar produced the most economical spell of the day, taking three wickets for two runs in three overs, including a maiden, as Janakpur collapsed to 88. His captain Sikandar Raza, Kamal Singh Airee and Kamil Mishra took two wickets each, and Rijan Dhakal took one, and Janakpur never built a partnership of any size. Their captain Harmeet Singh top-scored with 25, and only two other batsmen reached double figures.
Even chasing 89, Chitwan felt the pitch. They lost five wickets in the powerplay and were 37 for 5 before Dawid Malan and Kushal Malla steadied the innings with a 30-run stand. Malan finished unbeaten on 35 from 39 balls, and Chitwan got home with 16 balls to spare. Rahul Yadav took three wickets for Janakpur, Harmeet Singh two, and Bishal Shusling one, and for a while a total of 88 looked like it might be enough.
The first match followed the same script from the other side. Sudurpaschim captain Dipendra Singh Airee held his side together with 60 from 55 balls, with two sixes and five fours, while Thilindu Ratnayake made an unbeaten 26 and Arif Sheikh 16. Kathmandu's Jahanbad Khan took three wickets and Santosh Yadav two, and the Royals were kept to 125 for 6. Chasing 126, Kathmandu received 20 extras and still fell seven runs short, with Rashid Khan unbeaten on 35 from 31 balls and Dushan Hemantha making 21 from 18. Anil Kharel took two wickets for Sudurpaschim, and Scott Kuggeleijn, Hemant Dhami and Fabian Allen took one each.
The defining bowling performance of the week, though, came a day earlier. Sandeep Lamichhane took six wickets, including a hat-trick, as Biratnagar bowled Pokhara out for 132. It was the kind of spell that settles a debate: on this pitch, a bowler with control and variation is worth more than a batsman with power.
What the players are saying
The players have not hidden what they think of the surface. Hemant Dhami, the young Sudurpaschim bowler who bowled the final over of the first match on Friday, said his plan was to take pace off the ball and bowl cutters, because the ball was turning on the pitch. With 24 needed from the last three overs, Kuggeleijn conceded five in the 19th and Dhami nine in the 20th, and Kathmandu finished seven runs short. Dhami said working with senior players and with Kuggeleijn has improved his game. On this pitch, change of pace beats raw pace.
Kathmandu's young bowler Ganesh Gautam made the same point from the losing side. He said Kathmandu had planned their bowling and batting around a pitch that was assisting spinners, and that dropped catches in the field let Sudurpaschim score more than they should have. The target of 126 was not too big, in his view. The batting simply did not perform as expected.
Dawid Malan, who saw Chitwan home in the second match, was the most direct. He said the ball turned a lot in the first innings and that batting became somewhat easier in the second only because dew made the ball slippery. He added that a target of 120 would have made the game entirely different, and that batsmen face real challenges scoring runs on pitches in Nepal. In many Twenty20 leagues around the world, he said, batsmen dominate. In Nepal, the bowlers get more help. A pitch that allows 150 to 160, he said, would make the games more competitive and more exciting.
Janakpur head coach Shivnarayan Chandrapal looked at the same pitch and drew a different lesson. He said his batsmen should have been able to take singles and rotate the strike even on a difficult surface, and that they failed to do so. He pointed to dropped catches and to spinners who did not perform as expected, and said he had advised his players to play to the off side and take singles instead of playing the sweep shot, only for the advice to be ignored on the next ball. His frustration was with decision-making under pressure, not with the surface itself.
Even the stars are struggling
The pitch is not sparing reputations. David Warner, the biggest name in the league, managed 127 runs in his four matches for Kathmandu, with one hard-fought half-century of 66, before returning home. Jimmy Neesham, the experienced New Zealand all-rounder, made nought from eight balls for Janakpur on Friday. Sikandar Raza, the Chitwan captain, has been far quieter with the bat than his reputation suggests. These are players who have scored runs in international cricket and in franchise leagues around the world, and at Kirtipur they are fighting for every run like everyone else.
That is what makes the debate about the pitch more than a complaint. When overseas stars and local players struggle alike, the surface becomes the story. The bowlers, meanwhile, are producing the performances of the season: six-wicket hauls, hat-tricks, spells of three wickets for two runs. The balance of the contest has tilted, and it has tilted a long way.
There is a counter-argument, and it deserves to be heard. Low-scoring matches can be thrilling, and Friday proved it: both games went deep, both were in the balance late, and both were decided by small margins and fine bowling rather than by one-sided batting. A target of 126 that is defended by seven runs is a better contest than a target of 200 that is chased down with overs to spare. The question is not whether low scores are entertaining. It is whether every match should be low-scoring, and whether batsmen should have a fair chance to play their shots.
The comparison with the first season hangs over the discussion. That season is remembered for a better balance between bat and ball, with totals that gave both disciplines a chance and plenty of close finishes. The second and third seasons have drifted away from that balance, and the last five matches have made the drift impossible to miss. If the pattern holds through the playoffs, the team that bowls best, rather than the team that bats best, will lift the trophy.
What it means for the final weekend
The pitch will matter more than ever in the three league matches that remain, because all three are now live playoff games. Biratnagar Kings face Lumbini Lions on Saturday, 14 November, at 5:00 PM NST in a straight elimination match: lose, and they are out. Chitwan Rhinos meet Karnali Yaks on Sunday, 15 November, at 12:30 PM NST, and Kathmandu Gorkhas play Pokhara Avengers later that day at 5:00 PM NST.
For Biratnagar, the surface is both a problem and an opportunity. Their captain Sandeep Lamichhane has just shown what a bowler can do on it, and a low total against Lumbini would bring their attack into the game. But their batting must also find a way to post a score, and their net run rate of minus 0.524 means they almost certainly need to win well, not just win. Chitwan, on seven points, can reach the playoffs by beating Karnali, and their bowling attack, led by Ranjit Kumar and Raza, is built for exactly these conditions. Kathmandu, on eight points, need a win over Pokhara to be sure, and their bowlers showed on Friday that they can defend a small total, even if their batsmen could not chase one.
The team that adapts fastest to Kirtipur will decide the last two playoff places. Friday showed that defending a small total is possible, that chasing one is never comfortable, and that the bowlers will have the final say. The batsmen have three matches left to prove otherwise.
FAQs
Why are scores so low at the TU Ground in NPL Season 3?
The last five completed matches at the TU International Cricket Ground in Kirtipur have all been low-scoring: the highest total in ten innings was 132, and three sides failed to reach 100. On Friday, Sudurpaschim made 125 and Kathmandu 118, while Janakpur made 88 and Chitwan 92 for 6.
What is wrong with the TU Ground pitch?
The pitch is slow, the ball does not come onto the bat with expected pace, and it assists spinners with turn and medium-pacers with cutters and changes of pace. Batsmen have struggled to time shots, and even small targets such as 89 and 126 have been hard to chase.
What have the players said about the Kirtipur pitch?
Hemant Dhami said his plan was to bowl cutters and take pace off because the ball was turning. Dawid Malan said the ball turned a lot in the first innings, that dew made batting easier in the second innings, and that bowlers get more help on pitches in Nepal than in other Twenty20 leagues.
When are the remaining NPL league matches?
Biratnagar Kings face Lumbini Lions on Saturday, 14 November at 5:00 PM NST. On Sunday, 15 November, Chitwan Rhinos meet Karnali Yaks at 12:30 PM NST and Kathmandu Gorkhas play Pokhara Avengers at 5:00 PM NST. All three matches are at the TU International Cricket Ground in Kirtipur.
Comments