NPL Season 3

Neesham Slams TU Pitches as NPL Debate Grows

The debate over the TU Ground pitches has gone public. Hours after falling for a duck in Janakpur Bolts' defeat to Chitwan Rhinos, Jimmy Neesham said something serious had to be done about the surfaces in Kirtipur, arguing that 120 runs could not keep being enough to win a match in the tournament. By Friday night, the Cricket Association of Nepal had responded, saying it had spoken to the curator and expected conditions to improve before the playoffs. Neesham's intervention carries weight because of who he is and when it came: the 35-year-old New Zealand all-rounder was the overseas star around whom Janakpur built their first title win in 2024, scoring 247 runs in nine matches at a strike rate above 196 and taking seven wickets, and his post arrived on the night Janakpur were knocked out of the league stage, bowled out for 88 in the match they most needed to win.

Reading6 min
Words1223+
Action from the Janakpur Bolts against Chitwan Rhinos match at the TU International Cricket Ground in Kirtipur Photo: OnlineKhabar
Jimmy Neesham has taken the debate over the TU Ground pitches public. Hours after making a duck in Janakpur Bolts' defeat to Chitwan Rhinos, the New Zealand all-rounder said something serious had to be done about the surfaces in Kirtipur, arguing that 120 runs could not keep being enough to win a match. The governing body has responded, saying it has spoken to the curator and expects conditions to improve before the playoffs.

Advertisement

Quick Facts

The post
Neesham says 120 runs cannot keep being enough to win, and calls for serious action on the Kirtipur pitches.
Friday at Kirtipur
Sudurpaschim 125/6 beat Kathmandu 118/7 by 7 runs; Chitwan 92/6 beat Janakpur 88 by 4 wickets
Season numbers
Batting first, sides have passed 150 only 9 times in 25 matches; four first innings have not reached 100
The response
The Cricket Association of Nepal says curator talks are under way and better conditions are expected
Remaining matches
Biratnagar vs Lumbini, Sat 14 Nov 5:00 PM NST; Chitwan vs Karnali, Sun 15 Nov 12:30 PM NST; Kathmandu vs Pokhara, Sun 15 Nov 5:00 PM NST

The debate over the TU Ground pitches has gone public. Hours after falling for a duck in Janakpur Bolts' defeat to Chitwan Rhinos, Jimmy Neesham said something serious had to be done about the surfaces in Kirtipur, arguing that 120 runs could not keep being enough to win a match in the tournament. By Friday night, the Cricket Association of Nepal had responded, saying it had spoken to the curator and expected conditions to improve before the playoffs. Neesham's intervention carries weight because of who he is and when it came: the 35-year-old New Zealand all-rounder was the overseas star around whom Janakpur built their first title win in 2024, scoring 247 runs in nine matches at a strike rate above 196 and taking seven wickets, and his post arrived on the night Janakpur were knocked out of the league stage, bowled out for 88 in the match they most needed to win.

Advertisement

The post that turned a debate into a row

The post itself was short and direct. Neesham said he loved coming to Nepal and playing in the Nepal Premier League, but that something serious needed to be done about the pitches. A total of 120, he wrote, could not be enough to win right through a tournament. The words landed because they matched what everyone at the ground had just watched: Janakpur, chasing a playoff place, had been bowled out for 88 in 20 overs, the lowest total by a side that batted out its full allocation this season, and even the modest chase of 89 had cost Chitwan six wickets and 17.2 overs.

Neesham had felt the pitch himself. He faced eight balls against Chitwan and made nought, the latest reminder that the surface has been sparing no reputation. David Warner, the biggest name in the league, managed 127 runs in four matches before returning home. Three days earlier, against Sudurpaschim, Neesham had made 20 from 25 balls in a chase of 121 that Janakpur lost by 27 runs. The duck on Friday was the sharper statement: a batsman of his class, on this pitch, could not buy a run.

Advertisement

A chorus, not a lone voice

Neesham was not the first player to say so out loud. His post joined a chorus that has been building all week. Dawid Malan, who carried Chitwan home on Friday with an unbeaten 35 from 39 balls, called the pitch very tricky and said the bowlers had done well. Had Chitwan been asked to chase 120 on the same surface, he said, they would have been under a different kind of pressure altogether. He added that it was good for bowlers to be favoured, but that at Kirtipur they were being favoured a bit too much, and that totals of 150 to 160 would make the games more competitive. He expected the pitches to improve in the coming days.

Ravi Bopara, Chitwan's veteran, who has played in all three seasons of the league, was blunter still. The pitches had not been the best this season, he said, and were probably the worst he had seen of them. He added a note of hope: the pitch on the day he spoke had been a good one, and there were positive signs for the run-in.

Advertisement

The coaches had been saying it even earlier. Kathmandu's technical director Sharad Vesawkar, Biratnagar's head coach Dhammika Prasad and Lumbini's consultant coach Shakti Gauchan had all described the pitch as challenging before Friday's matches, and the two matches since have only underlined their point. Biratnagar's owner Paras Luniya went further, saying the behaviour of the pitches had not been consistent from match to match, and that his own team often did not know what sort of surface they would get. In a format built on fours and sixes, he said, that uncertainty itself was a problem. Former Nepal international Prithu Baskota added that low-scoring games could still thrill, but that batsmen needed to be able to score a few more runs than they have been.

Advertisement

The numbers behind the frustration

The numbers explain why the players are talking. After 25 matches, the side batting first has passed 150 only nine times, and four first innings have failed to reach 100. Five matches in a row have now been low-scoring, and the highest total in the ten innings of those five matches was 136. Three of those ten innings ended below 100. In a format where 170 to 180 is a par score in most franchise leagues, Kirtipur has been producing something entirely different, and teams have changed how they play because of it: after spending the first fortnight almost always bowling first, they chose to bat first in each of the three matches before Friday, and Janakpur did the same on Friday after winning the toss.

The contrast with the first season hangs over the discussion. That season is remembered for a better balance between bat and ball, with totals that gave both disciplines a chance and plenty of close finishes. The second and third seasons have drifted away from that balance. Low scores are not automatically bad cricket: Friday's two games both went deep and were decided by small margins and fine bowling. But a tournament in which 120 is regularly enough to win is a different problem, and the warning now goes beyond entertainment. If the pitches stay this hard to bat on, the league risks boring the crowds who come to see big hits, discouraging the overseas batsmen it wants to attract next season, and watching its home batsmen lose form and confidence with them.

Advertisement

Why the pitches are playing this way

Part of the answer lies in August, when the pitches at the TU Ground were repaired. The crucial factor, the governing body's vice-president Roshan Singh explained at the time, is how long the grass stays on the wicket: as long as it stays, the pitch remains good, and once it dies off the surface turns flat. For grass roots to reach four inches deep and bind the soil together takes about four months. The pitches did not get that time. The league kicked off on 26 October, barely two months after the repair work, and the surfaces have been wearing as the tournament has gone on.

Advertisement

What the governing body says

The governing body has now acknowledged the problem in public. Its vice-president, Roshan Singh, said it was hard to predict how a pitch would behave before the tournament, and that everything depended on how the surface was prepared, read and looked after. He said the secretary, Paras Khadka, had already discussed the matter with the curator, and that he expected conditions to be better in the matches ahead. The promise will be tested immediately: three league matches remain, all of them live playoff games, and all of them on the same ground.

Advertisement

What it means for the final weekend

Biratnagar Kings face Lumbini Lions on Saturday, 14 November, at 5:00 PM NST in a straight elimination match: lose, and they are out. Chitwan Rhinos meet Karnali Yaks on Sunday, 15 November, at 12:30 PM NST, and Kathmandu Gorkhas play Pokhara Avengers later that day at 5:00 PM NST. Neesham's Janakpur will not be there. Their season ended on Friday with four points from seven matches, and their overseas star's parting shot was aimed at the very ground where the last two playoff places will be decided. The bowlers have owned this tournament. The question for the final weekend is whether the pitches will let the batsmen have a say before the playoffs begin.

Read Also: Slow TU Pitch Turns NPL Into a Bowlers' League

FAQs

What did Jimmy Neesham say about the TU Ground pitches?

Neesham said he loved coming to Nepal and playing in the Nepal Premier League, but that something serious needed to be done about the pitches. In his words, 120 runs could not be enough to win right through a tournament.

Why are the pitches at the TU Ground so hard to bat on?

The surfaces are slow, the ball does not come onto the bat, and they assist spinners with turn and medium-pacers with cutters and changes of pace. The pitches were also repaired only in August, without the four months the grass roots need to bind the soil, so they have worn as the tournament has gone on.

What has the Cricket Association of Nepal said about the pitches?

Its vice-president, Roshan Singh, said it was hard to predict how a pitch would behave before the tournament and that everything depended on preparation and maintenance. He said the secretary, Paras Khadka, had discussed the matter with the curator, and that better conditions were expected in the matches ahead.

When are the remaining NPL league matches?

Biratnagar Kings face Lumbini Lions on Saturday, 14 November at 5:00 PM NST. On Sunday, 15 November, Chitwan Rhinos meet Karnali Yaks at 12:30 PM NST and Kathmandu Gorkhas play Pokhara Avengers at 5:00 PM NST. All three matches are at the TU International Cricket Ground in Kirtipur.

Comments

  1. No comments yet. Be the first to share your view.

Leave a comment

Your email is never shown publicly. Comments appear after approval.